*Spoiler Alert: This post is about the Broadway musical "Spring Awakening," which I don't think you should see. If you plan on seeing it anyway, you might not want to read on.
"Spring Awakening" may be the worst musical I've ever seen.Mind you, I don't know enough show tunes to last a night at Marie's Crisis, but I can give a stereotypical gay man of my generation a run for his money. I filled in my bra listening to "Rent," "West Side Story," "A Chorus Line," and "Cabaret." At the end of high school, I realized I might have missed out: "Exile in Guyville? What is this? Who's Liz Phair?"
I'm occasionally open to seeing new musicals, because everything amazing has to start as a seed. I'm not into spectacles, though. I have no desire to see "Hairspray" or "Wicked," and I'm waiting to see the film version of "Mamma Mia."
But I thought "Spring Awakening" would be different. It won a lot of Tonys, so it couldn't be cloying and preposterous, right? Wrong! I knew it was hyped, but I thought, "Ooh, Duncan Sheik did the music and it's about adolescence. It's got a lot of people talking, due to some risque scenes." A friend had access to some discount tickets, courtesy of NYU, and I was in. I was excited to take TBID, who hasn't seen a Broadway musical since he had to write a report on it in middle school, because I wanted to show him that musical theater can rock.
And "Spring Awakening" does rock, if you like All-American Rejects rejects. Consider the fact that not a year ago, you couldn't shop at a major retailer without hearing such lyrical gems as, "I'm hot because I'm fly. You ain't cause you not. This is why, this is why I'm hot..." The poppy soundtrack of this musical was so uncatchy, with some lyrics that were so incomprehensible, that even mainstream radio wouldn't want it.
Not to mention that the show is completely implausible. All adults are played by the same two actors, because adults in the show are caricatures. They are all ignorant, with the exception of Melchior's mother, who succumbs to her husband's rule and plays dumb in the end. The teenage characters are undeveloped and just as unsympathetic. To tell you the story in a busted nutshell: Adults in "Spring Awakening" don't want to talk to their children about sex, and then the world ends.
I'm an advocate of sex education, and I don't mean the abstinence-only kind. But I know that sexual urges are not so all-consuming that they make teenagers explode and civilizations crumble. The writers of "Spring Awakening" would have audiences believe that one character commits suicide as a result of feeling sexually constrained. (There are other factors to this plot point, of course, but the sexual factor is the most apparent). I could understand if the play were about how adults can be unfair, but that was overshadowed by the themes of sexual taboos and exploration.
It was like watching something some high schoolers cooked up when the power went out one day when they'd been in the middle of a Real World marathon - the acting was that self-conscious and hackneyed. In a romantic scene between two gay characters, the actors got cheeky and made weird faces while singing about sex. The audience laughed; homophobia scored one more point.
I couldn't bring myself to applaud anything I saw or heard. The musical numbers, like I said, were very poppy, but not in a good way. One in which a girl sings about incest had the audience bopping their heads, and I don't know about you, but that weirds me out.
It was all shock, not to be confused with shock value. The shocking thing wasn't a bare breast or butt or the song wherein a character simulates masturbation the entire time. It was that some critics have lauded "Spring Awakening."
At the curtain call, TBID and I stayed in our seats. He looked at me, nervous about what to say. "I thought it was awful," I finally spat out. He sighed. "Oh, I'm so glad."
Labels: Liberal Arts - Holla.


<< Home